The world of soccer video games is dominated by the FIFA series, with each new installment bringing significant improvements and enhancements to the gaming experience. Two of the most popular titles in the series are FIFA 17 and FIFA 18, both of which have their own unique features and gameplay mechanics. In this article, we will delve into the details of each game, comparing their features, gameplay, and overall experience to determine which one is better.
Introduction to FIFA 17 and FIFA 18
FIFA 17 was released in 2016 and marked a significant shift in the series, as it introduced a new game engine, Frostbite, which provided more realistic graphics and gameplay. The game also featured a new single-player story mode, called “The Journey,” which allowed players to experience the life of a professional soccer player. On the other hand, FIFA 18 was released in 2017 and built upon the foundations laid by its predecessor. It introduced new features such as Real Player Motion Technology, which enhanced the game’s animation and movement systems.
Gameplay Comparison
One of the most significant differences between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 is the gameplay. FIFA 17 introduced a more physical and tactical approach to the game, with an emphasis on player positioning and teamwork. The game’s set piece system was also overhauled, allowing for more variety and strategy in dead-ball situations. In contrast, FIFA 18 focused on speed and agility, with faster player movement and more responsive controls. The game’s dribbling system was also improved, allowing for more intricate and realistic ball control.
Player Movement and Animation
FIFA 18’s Real Player Motion Technology is a significant improvement over FIFA 17’s animation system. The new technology allows for more realistic player movement, with more fluid and natural animations. Players can now change direction quickly and make sharp turns, making the game feel more responsive and immersive. In contrast, FIFA 17’s animation system, while still good, can feel a bit stiff and robotic at times.
Features and Modes
Both FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 offer a range of features and modes, including Ultimate Team, Career Mode, and Online Seasons. However, FIFA 18 introduces some new features, such as Quick Subs, which allow players to make substitutions during the game without having to pause the action. The game also features an improved transfer system in Career Mode, allowing for more realistic and complex transfer negotiations.
Ultimate Team Mode
Ultimate Team is one of the most popular modes in the FIFA series, and both FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 offer a range of features and improvements. In FIFA 17, Ultimate Team introduced a new Chemistry System, which rewards players for building a team with a strong chemistry and cohesion. FIFA 18 builds upon this system, introducing new icons and legendary players to the mode. The game also features an improved squad building system, making it easier for players to build and manage their teams.
Career Mode and Online Seasons
Career Mode is another popular mode in the FIFA series, allowing players to manage and control their own team over the course of several seasons. FIFA 18 introduces some significant improvements to Career Mode, including an improved transfer system and new player negotiation options. The game also features an improved online mode, with more realistic and competitive online seasons.
Graphics and Soundtrack
Both FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 feature stunning graphics and realistic sound effects. However, FIFA 18’s graphics are slightly more refined, with more detailed player models and improved lighting effects. The game’s soundtrack is also more diverse and energetic, featuring a range of popular and emerging artists.
Soundtrack and Commentary
The soundtrack in FIFA 18 is more upbeat and energetic than in FIFA 17, with a range of popular and emerging artists. The game’s commentary is also more realistic and immersive, with more varied and detailed commentary from the game’s commentators. The commentary team, which includes Martin Tyler and Alan Smith, provides a more authentic and engaging experience, with more insightful and informative commentary.
Stadiums and Atmosphere
Both FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 feature realistic and detailed stadiums, with authentic crowd noises and atmospheric effects. However, FIFA 18’s stadiums are slightly more detailed and realistic, with more varied and authentic crowd reactions. The game’s atmosphere is also more electric and immersive, with more realistic and intense crowd noises and effects.
| Feature | FIFA 17 | FIFA 18 |
|---|---|---|
| Game Engine | Frostbite | Frostbite |
| Gameplay | Physical and tactical | Fast-paced and agile |
| Features | Ultimate Team, Career Mode, Online Seasons | Ultimate Team, Career Mode, Online Seasons, Quick Subs |
| Graphics | Realistic and detailed | More refined and detailed |
| Soundtrack | Good but not great | More diverse and energetic |
Conclusion
In conclusion, both FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 are excellent soccer video games, each with their own unique features and gameplay mechanics. However, FIFA 18 is the better game, with its improved gameplay, new features, and refined graphics. The game’s Real Player Motion Technology and Quick Subs feature make it a more responsive and immersive experience, while its improved transfer system and new icons in Ultimate Team mode make it a more realistic and engaging experience. If you’re a fan of the FIFA series, FIFA 18 is the better choice, but if you’re looking for a more physical and tactical gameplay experience, FIFA 17 may be the better option.
- FIFA 18’s improved gameplay and new features make it the better game
- FIFA 17’s physical and tactical gameplay may be preferred by some players
- Both games offer a range of features and modes, including Ultimate Team and Career Mode
- FIFA 18’s graphics and soundtrack are more refined and diverse
- The game’s atmosphere and stadiums are more realistic and immersive
Overall, the choice between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 depends on your personal preferences and gaming style. If you value fast-paced and agile gameplay, improved graphics, and new features, FIFA 18 is the better choice. However, if you prefer a more physical and tactical gameplay experience, FIFA 17 may be the better option.
What are the key differences between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18?
The key differences between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18 lie in their gameplay mechanics, graphics, and features. FIFA 18 introduced a new game engine, allowing for more realistic player movements and interactions. Additionally, FIFA 18 features improved graphics, with more detailed player models and stadiums. The game also includes new modes, such as the “Ultimate Team” mode, which allows players to build and manage their own teams. In contrast, FIFA 17 has more arcade-like gameplay, with faster player movements and a greater emphasis on scoring goals.
In terms of specific features, FIFA 18 includes a new “Real Player Motion Technology” system, which allows for more realistic player movements and animations. The game also features a new “Interactive Match Atmosphere” system, which allows for more immersive and realistic crowd interactions. Furthermore, FIFA 18 includes a new “Player Personality” system, which allows players to customize their players’ personalities and playing styles. Overall, while both games offer similar gameplay experiences, FIFA 18’s improved graphics, new features, and more realistic gameplay mechanics make it a more immersive and engaging experience for players.
How do the graphics compare between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18?
The graphics in FIFA 18 are significantly improved compared to FIFA 17. FIFA 18 features more detailed player models, with more realistic facial expressions and body movements. The game also includes more detailed stadiums, with more realistic lighting and textures. Additionally, FIFA 18 features improved crowd graphics, with more realistic crowd movements and interactions. In contrast, FIFA 17’s graphics are more dated, with less detailed player models and stadiums. However, FIFA 17’s graphics are still impressive, with smooth and fast gameplay.
The improved graphics in FIFA 18 are due in part to the game’s new game engine, which allows for more detailed and realistic graphics. The game also includes a new “Dynamic Weather” system, which allows for more realistic weather effects and conditions. Furthermore, FIFA 18 features a new “Stadium Atmosphere” system, which allows for more immersive and realistic stadium environments. Overall, while both games offer impressive graphics, FIFA 18’s improved graphics and more realistic gameplay mechanics make it a more visually stunning and engaging experience for players.
What new features does FIFA 18 offer compared to FIFA 17?
FIFA 18 offers several new features compared to FIFA 17, including a new “Ultimate Team” mode, which allows players to build and manage their own teams. The game also includes a new “Career Mode” feature, which allows players to manage their own teams and make decisions on player transfers and tactics. Additionally, FIFA 18 features a new “Player Personality” system, which allows players to customize their players’ personalities and playing styles. The game also includes a new “Real Player Motion Technology” system, which allows for more realistic player movements and animations.
The new features in FIFA 18 are designed to provide a more immersive and engaging experience for players. The “Ultimate Team” mode, for example, allows players to build and manage their own teams, and compete against other players online. The “Career Mode” feature, on the other hand, allows players to manage their own teams and make decisions on player transfers and tactics, providing a more realistic and challenging experience. Overall, the new features in FIFA 18 make it a more comprehensive and engaging game compared to FIFA 17.
How does the gameplay compare between FIFA 17 and FIFA 18?
The gameplay in FIFA 18 is more realistic and immersive compared to FIFA 17. FIFA 18 features more realistic player movements and interactions, with a greater emphasis on strategy and tactics. The game also includes a new “Real Player Motion Technology” system, which allows for more realistic player movements and animations. In contrast, FIFA 17 has more arcade-like gameplay, with faster player movements and a greater emphasis on scoring goals. However, both games offer fast-paced and exciting gameplay, with a wide range of teams and players to choose from.
The gameplay in FIFA 18 is designed to provide a more realistic and challenging experience for players. The game’s new “Real Player Motion Technology” system, for example, allows for more realistic player movements and animations, making it more difficult for players to score goals. The game also includes a new “Defensive Tactics” system, which allows players to customize their team’s defensive strategy and make more informed decisions on the pitch. Overall, while both games offer exciting gameplay, FIFA 18’s more realistic and immersive gameplay mechanics make it a more engaging and challenging experience for players.
Is FIFA 18 worth upgrading from FIFA 17?
Whether or not FIFA 18 is worth upgrading from FIFA 17 depends on the individual player’s preferences and needs. If you’re looking for a more realistic and immersive gameplay experience, with improved graphics and new features, then FIFA 18 may be worth upgrading to. However, if you’re happy with the gameplay and features in FIFA 17, and don’t feel the need for the latest and greatest, then you may not need to upgrade. Additionally, if you’re on a budget, you may want to consider waiting for a sale or discount before purchasing FIFA 18.
Ultimately, the decision to upgrade to FIFA 18 from FIFA 17 depends on your individual circumstances and preferences. If you’re a hardcore FIFA fan, and want to experience the latest and greatest in gameplay and features, then FIFA 18 is definitely worth considering. However, if you’re a casual player, or on a tight budget, then you may want to stick with FIFA 17 or wait for a sale or discount. It’s also worth noting that FIFA 18 is available on a range of platforms, including PC, Xbox, and PlayStation, so you can choose the version that best suits your needs and preferences.
What are the system requirements for FIFA 18 compared to FIFA 17?
The system requirements for FIFA 18 are more demanding compared to FIFA 17. FIFA 18 requires a more powerful processor, more memory, and a more advanced graphics card to run smoothly. Specifically, FIFA 18 requires a minimum of 8 GB of RAM, a 3.4 GHz processor, and an NVIDIA GeForce GTX 660 or AMD Radeon HD 7850 graphics card. In contrast, FIFA 17 requires a minimum of 4 GB of RAM, a 3.0 GHz processor, and an NVIDIA GeForce GTX 460 or AMD Radeon HD 5870 graphics card.
The more demanding system requirements for FIFA 18 are due to the game’s improved graphics and gameplay mechanics. The game’s new “Real Player Motion Technology” system, for example, requires more processing power and memory to run smoothly. Additionally, the game’s improved graphics and lighting effects require a more advanced graphics card to render. However, if you have a high-end gaming PC or console, you should be able to run FIFA 18 smoothly and enjoy the game’s improved graphics and gameplay mechanics. It’s also worth noting that the system requirements for FIFA 18 may vary depending on the platform and region you’re playing in.